# Bharat's Commentary on HINDU SUCCESSION ACT, 1956 by Neelam Kumar Jain

|     |
| --- |
| About Commentary on HINDU SUCCESSION ACT, 1956 |
|     |
| CHAPTER I<br><br>Preliminary<br><br>1 Short title and extent<br><br>1. Preamble — Object of the Act<br><br>2. Rules of interpretation of Title and Preamble<br><br>3. Codification of a particular branch of the law<br><br>4. Aid of the General Clauses Act, 1897 in interpreting the Statute<br><br>5. Date of commencement and coming into operation of the Act<br><br>6. Hindu Law being a personal law is not lex loci — Personal Law: Rule of presumption<br><br>(i) Migration and school of law<br><br>(ii) Migrating Families<br><br>2 Application of Act<br><br>1. Interpretation and scope of section 2<br><br>2. Provisions of section 2 is in reference to intestate but not heirs<br><br>3. Christians, Muslims, Parsis or Jews are not governed by the Hindu Succession Act<br><br>(3-i) Illustration of Jujjavarapu Yesurao v Nadakuduru Kamala Kumar case<br><br>4. Word ‘Hindu’— Connotation of<br><br>(1) Illustration of R. Sridharan case<br><br>(2) Illustration of Balasubramanian v Vidya case<br><br>5. Jains included in the term ‘Hindu’ even if their religion is different<br><br>6. Term ‘Hindu law’<br><br>7. Act does not apply to the members of a Scheduled Tribe<br><br>(1) Scheduled Tribes — meaning<br><br>(2) Act not applicable to custom governed tribals<br><br>(3) Illustration of Kamla Neti case<br><br>(4) Members of Scheduled Tribes who are Hinduised and follow Hindu traditions<br><br>(5) Bathudis sub caste<br><br>(6) Scheduled Tribe may be governed by the old Hindu Law<br><br>(7) Whether provisions of the Act can protanto apply<br><br>(8) Pleadings and proof for applicability of custom<br><br>8. Law of succession applicable to Christians in Pondicherry<br><br>(1) Act not applicable to the Renoncants \[s. 2(2A) of the Hindu Succession Act (Pondicherry)\]<br><br>(2) Extract of report of Mr. Gandhiraj, Government Pleader (Pondicherry)<br><br>(3) Illustration of Theiry Santhanamal v Viswanathan case<br><br>9. Succession in case of a person entered into a religious order<br><br>(9-i) Illustration of Sumer Chand case<br><br>10. Succession in case of a ‘Transgender’ dying intestate<br><br>11. The Hindu Succession Act is not retrospective in operation<br><br>12. Succession is governed by the law in force at the time succession opens<br><br>13. No divesting on account of widow’s remarriage or unchastity<br><br>3 Definitions and interpretations<br><br>1. Definitions — interpretation<br><br>(1) Unless the context otherwise requires — Connotation<br><br>(2) Meaning of the word ‘Context’<br><br>2. Expression ‘related by blood’<br><br>3. Custom or usage<br><br>(1) Illustration of Munnalal v Rajkumar case<br><br>(2) Illustration of Babulal v Resmabai case<br><br>4. Expression ‘heir’<br><br>5. Devolution of property based on concept of kinship<br><br>6. Expression ‘related’ in Section 3(1)(j)<br><br>7. Relation by adoption<br><br>8. Words child, son or daughter— rule of construction<br><br>9. Illegitimate children<br><br>10. Word ‘wife’<br><br>11. Words importing the masculine gender shall not be taken to include females<br><br>4 Overriding effect of Act<br><br>1. Extent, Scope and object of overriding application<br><br>2. Fiction of relation back in the case of adoption<br><br>3. Custom of Joridari system stood abrogated<br><br>4. Provision for succession to ‘agricultural land’ not ultra vires<br><br>5. Overriding effect over customary law of the Punjab<br><br>6. Right of son's son in his grandfather's property<br><br>7. Overriding effect over the Hindu Widows’ Re-Marriage Act, 1856<br><br>(7-i) Illustration of Harabati v Jasodhara Debi case<br><br>8. Overriding effect over Mysore Hindu Law Women's Right to Property Act<br><br>9. No overriding effect on matters not provided for in the Act<br><br>(1) Wife’s or mother's right to a share on partition has not been abrogated<br><br>(2) Female member’s right to sue for partition<br><br>10. Omitted sub-section (2) of Section 4<br><br>11. Succession in respect of agricultural land<br><br>12. General observation of the Parliamentary standing committee regarding s. 4(2)<br><br>13. Bhumidhari and Bhumiswami rights under Madhya Pradesh Land Revenue Code<br><br>14. The Madhya Pradesh Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings Act, 1960<br><br>15. The U. P. Zamindari Abolition and Land Reforms Act<br><br>16. Succession to bhumidhari rights under Delhi Land Reforms Act, 1954<br><br>17. Scope and effect of a ‘Declaratory decree’—<br><br>18. Consequence of ‘compromise decree’<br><br>CHAPTER II<br><br>Intestate Succession<br><br>General<br><br>5 Act not to apply to certain properties<br><br>1. The Act does not apply to certain properties<br><br>2. Succession in case of a Hindu whose marriage is solemnized under Special Marriage Act<br><br>(2-i) Illustration of Archana Arun Palav v Jennifer Michael<br><br>(2-ii) Illustration of Menaka Gandhi v Indira Gandhi case<br><br>3. Object and scope of section 5(ii)<br><br>4. History of integration of princely states<br><br>5. Definitions of “Indian State” and “Ruler”<br><br>6. Impartible estates — origin, nature and scope<br><br>7. Rule of Primogeniture<br><br>8. Succession in case of impartible estate and the effect of the Hindu Succession Act thereon<br><br>(8-i) Illustration Tikka Shatrujit Singh v Brig Sukhjit Singh<br><br>(8-ii) Illustration of Revathinnal Balagopala v Padmanabha Dasa (Travancore case)<br><br>(8-iii) Illustration of Deepinder Kaur v Amrit Kaur case<br><br>9. Non applicability of the Act to the Valiamma Thampuran Kovilagam Estate and the Palace Fund<br><br>(9-i) Illustration of Krishnakumari Thampuran v The Palace Administration Board<br><br>6 Devolution of interest in coparcenary property<br><br>1. Joint Hindu family concept, history and old Hindu law<br><br>2. Composition of joint Hindu family under Mitakshara School<br><br>3. Coparcenary and Coparcener under Mitakshara School of Hindu Law<br><br>(1) Coparcenary under Mitakshara School<br><br>(2) Coparcener under Mitakshara School<br><br>4. Joint Hindu family and coparcenary under Dayabhaga School<br><br>5. Distinction between Mitakshara joint Hindu family and Hindu coparcenary<br><br>6. Incidents of coparcenership under the Mitakshara law<br><br>7. Coparcenary property under Mitakshara law<br><br>(1) Categories of coparcenary properties<br><br>(2) The word ‘ancestor’<br><br>(3) Doctrine of blending<br><br>(4) Death of a coparcener does not affect the status of Huf and coparcenary<br><br>(5) The Act has not abrogated the Mitakshara law completely<br><br>8. Creation or existence of Hindu Undivided Family and its property<br><br>9. Property acquired jointly by some members<br><br>10. Presumption and burden of proof regarding nature of property<br><br>11. Insurance policy amount — separate or joint family property<br><br>12. Rights of adopted son in Joint Family Property<br><br>(1) No Rights in the Joint Property held by the family of his birth<br><br>(2) Rights in the Joint Property held by the adoptive family<br><br>13. Son born out of null and void marriage -Right in coparcenary property<br><br>14. Power related to gift of Mitakshara Joint family or coparcenary property<br><br>15. Doctrine of devolution by survivorship<br><br>16. Devolution u/s 6 — applicability<br><br>17. Karta and manager of Joint Hindu Family<br><br>18. Alienation of Joint family/coparcenary property<br><br>(1) Alienation for legal necessity and adequate consideration<br><br>(2) Alienation of undivided interest in Joint family/coparcenary property<br><br>(3) Devise of undivided interest in coparcenary property by ‘will’<br><br>(4) Gift of undivided interest in the coparcenary property<br><br>(5) Renunciation of undivided interest in favour of all other coparceners is valid<br><br>(6) Mortgage of undivided share in a joint family property<br><br>19. Distinction between rights of a manager and a sole surviving coparcener regarding alienation<br><br>20. Father's full power of disposition over his self-acquired property<br><br>21. Rendition of accounts<br><br>22. Partition<br><br>(1) Partition meaning<br><br>(2) Severance of status by definite and unequivocal expression of intention to partition<br><br>(3) Separation of share<br><br>23. Hindu father’s power to partition the joint family property<br><br>(1) father’s power to make partition as patria potestas<br><br>(2) No right to make a partition by will<br><br>(3) Grandfather have no power to divide the properties<br><br>24. Divisible property on partition<br><br>(1) Property liable to be divided<br><br>(2) Properties indivisible by its nature<br><br>(3) Passage or common road<br><br>(4) Illustration of Raghunath v Biswanath case<br><br>25. How partition is made<br><br>26. Partial partition<br><br>27. Impact of partition<br><br>28. Date of severance of the joint status<br><br>29. Presumption regarding partition and burden of proof<br><br>30. Prepositions related to reopening of partition<br><br>31. Hindu joint family- reunion<br><br>(1) Concept of reunion<br><br>(2) Who can be reunited<br><br>(3) Intention to re-unite<br><br>(4) Consequence of reunion<br><br>(5) Presumption regarding reunion<br><br>(6) Illustration of R. Janakiammal v S.K. Kumarasamy case<br><br>32. Doctrine of Pious obligation under Hindu law<br><br>(1) Pious obligation under Hindu law, of sons, grandsons and great-grandsons<br><br>33. Wife not obliged to discharge the debts under the theory of pious obligation<br><br>34. Sale or mortgage of joint property for father’s debts<br><br>35. Onus to prove the character of the debt<br><br>36. Effect of the Hindu Succession Act on the doctrine of pious obligation<br><br>37. Amendment in section 6 by Amendment Act 39 of 2005<br><br>38. Constitutional validity of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 2005<br><br>39. Effect of repeal by Repealing and Amending Act, 2015<br><br>40. Rising needs for coparcenary rights to daughter \[Sub-s. (1) of Section 6\]<br><br>41. Amended Section 6 — an interpretive controversy<br><br>42. Coparcenary rights of daughters not ceased merely on passing of preliminary decree<br><br>(1) Preliminary decree in a partition suit<br><br>(2) Illustration of Danamma v Amar case<br><br>43. Proviso to sub-s. (1) of section 6 as amended by 2005 Amendment<br><br>(1) Expressions disposition, alienation and testamentary disposition — connotation of<br><br>(2) Constitutional validity of the proviso to Section 6(1)!<br><br>(3) Daughter's right to be a necessary party in a suit for partition<br><br>(4) Daughter's right where partition is not proved<br><br>(5) Central Amendment Act of 2005 prevails over the Karnataka Amendment Act, 1990<br><br>44. Female Hindu shall hold the property with the incidents of coparcenary ownership \[Sub-s. (2) of amended Section 6\]<br><br>45. Devolution of interest in Mitakshara joint family property \[Sub s. (3) of amended Section 6\]<br><br>46. Expression “interest in joint family property”<br><br>47. Deeming provision for determining the interest of a Hindu Mitakshara coparcener \[Explanation to sub s. (3) of amended s. 6\]<br><br>48. Abrogation of the doctrine of pious obligation \[Sub-s. (4) of amended section 6\]<br><br>(1) Amendment Act, 2005 abolished the doctrine of pious obligation<br><br>(2) If specified heirs explicitly consented to bind themself to discharge the obligation or parties to the suit, Section 6(4) will not apply<br><br>(3) Illustration of Upender Kumar Gupta case<br><br>49. Provisions of amended Section 6 not apply to a partition effected before 20.12.2004 \[Sub s. (5) of amended Section 6\]<br><br>(1) Deliberation by the Parliamentary Standing Committee<br><br>(2) Scope of sub s. (5) of amended Section 6<br><br>(3) Impact of the 2005 Amendment on the concept and modes of partition<br><br>(4) Expression ‘partition effected by a decree of a court’ — meaning of<br><br>(5) Share on ‘partition’<br><br>(5-i) Illustration of Basamma v Prabhu case<br><br>50. Suit for partition<br><br>(1) Illustration of Neelam v Sada Ram case<br><br>(2) Illustration of Ved Parkash v Naresh Kumar<br><br>51. Preliminary and final decree in a partition suit — scope of<br><br>(1) Preliminary decree can be amended in a partition suit<br><br>(2) No impediment for even passing more than one preliminary decree<br><br>(3) Preliminary decree can be changed even if not challenged by the party<br><br>52. Determination of the character of the property<br><br>(1) Ancestral property<br><br>(2) Unobstructed heritage and obstructed heritage<br><br>(3) Illustration of Om Parkash v Sarvjit Singh case<br><br>(4) Accretions and accumulations<br><br>(5) Separate property<br><br>(6) Property acquired merely by adverse possession<br><br>(7) Property received through gift or will from father<br><br>(8) Joint character does not change merely by severance of status of joint family<br><br>(9) Severance of joint family property is a question of fact<br><br>53. Nature of the property allotted on partition<br><br>54. Presumption regarding joint family property<br><br>55. Character of property governed by the law in force at the time succession opens<br><br>(1) Old doctrine of ancestral property under Mitakshara Hindu law changed post 1956<br><br>(2) Illustration of Arshnoor Singh v Harpal Kaur case<br><br>56. Character of ancestral property after partition and governing law to its succession<br><br>57. Commentary on old Section 6 (as existed before 2005 Amendment)<br><br>(1) Devolution of interest in Mitakshara coparcenary property by survivorship \[old Section 6\]<br><br>(2) Provisions of s. 6 do not apply without existence of a coparcenary<br><br>(2-a) Illustration of Ganta Appalanaidu case<br><br>58. Joint family property is synonymous with coparcenary property<br><br>59. Proviso to old s. 6 (as existed before 2005 Amendment)<br><br>(1) Proviso creates an exception to principles of survivorship<br><br>(2) Member having separate property does not mean not a member of the family<br><br>(3) Class I heirs inherit the interest simultaneously and as tenants-in-common<br><br>(4) Expressions “female relative” and “claims through”— connotation<br><br>(5) Illustration<br><br>(i) Case of Radhika Devi v Rajesh Kumar Niranjan<br><br>(ii) Case of Vishal v Derha<br><br>(6) Female heir inheriting property under proviso to old s. 6 not automatically ceased to be a member of the joint family<br><br>(7) No automatic partition on death of a coparcener<br><br>60. Necessary parties to a suit for recovery of debts<br><br>(1) Effect of non-inclusion of the parties in a suit<br><br>(2) Illustration 1- Case of P. Govinda Reddy v Golla Obulamma<br><br>(3) Illustration 2- Case of Narayan Prasad Ruia v Mutuni Kohain<br><br>(4) Illustration 3- Case of Govindram Mihamal v Chetumal Villardas<br><br>61. Non-coparcener female member can’t sue for partition<br><br>62. Explanation 1 to old s. 6 (as existed before 2005 Amendment)<br><br>(1) Determination of the interest of a Hindu Mitakshara coparcener on his death<br><br>(2) All heirs of a deceased coparcener entitled to get a share<br><br>(2-i) Case of Raj Rani v Chief Settlement Commissioner<br><br>63. Interpretation of legal fiction of partition<br><br>(1) Controversy and divergent views on interpretation of legal fiction of partition<br><br>(2) Fiction of deemed partition does not result into actual partition<br><br>64. Computation of the share due to the widow and other heirs of the deceased coparcener under Explanation 1 to s. 6<br><br>65. Separated coparcener not entitled to a share in the undivided interest \[Explanation 2 to old s. 6\]<br><br>7 Devolution of interest in the property of a Tarwad, Tavazhi, Kutumba, Kavaru or Illom<br><br>1. Marumakkattayam law of inheritance<br><br>2. Management, partition, distribution, character etc. of property under Marumakkattayam Law<br><br>(2-i) Illustration of Kalliyani Amma Bhavani Amma v Narayani Amma Madhavi Amma case<br><br>(2-ii) Illustration of C.T. Radhakrishnan v C.T. Viswanathan Nair case<br><br>3. Undivided interest in Tavazhi properties can be attached<br><br>4. Nambudri law<br><br>(4-i) Illustration of Sankaran Potti v Kochehi Krishnan case<br><br>(4-ii) Illustration of Sreedevi Antherjanam v Bhavadasan Namboodiri case<br><br>(4-iii) Illustration of Govind Potti Govindan Namboodiri v Kesavan case<br><br>5. Devolution of interest in the property of a tarwad, tavazhi or illom<br><br>6. Aliyasantana Law of inheritance<br><br>7. Partition of Aliyasantana family<br><br>(7-i) Illustration of Jalaja Shedthi v Lakshmi Shedthi case<br><br>8. Devolution of undivided interest in the property of aliyasantana kutumba or kavaru<br><br>(8-i) Illustration of Sundari v Laxmi case<br><br>9. Devolution of sthanam property held by sthanamdar<br><br>(1) Sthanam property and sthanamdar<br><br>(2) Devolution of sthanam property<br><br>(3) Illustration of Inspecting Assistant Commissioner v V.K. Ramunni Panikkar<br><br>(4) Incidents of sthanam<br><br>8 General rules of succession in the case of males<br><br>1. Scope and nature<br><br>2. Applicability of section 8<br><br>3. Provisions of s. 8 are not retrospective in operation<br><br>4. The expression ‘property’<br><br>(1) Expression ‘property’— Interpretation<br><br>(2) Agreement of sale can’t be enforced without absolute title to the property<br><br>(3) Illustration of Pemmada Prabhakar v Youngmen's Vysya Association case<br><br>(4) Illustration of Kirpal Kaur v Jitender Pal Singh case<br><br>(5) Right to get pension<br><br>5. Words ‘dying intestate’<br><br>6. Estoppel by Representation<br><br>7. Character of the property devolved u/s 8<br><br>(1) Misconception and controversy regarding the status of property inherited from father<br><br>(2) Property inherited by son u/s 8 is his individual Property<br><br>(3) Property allotted to a sole coparcener on partition<br><br>(4) Illustration<br><br>(i) Illustration of CWT v Chander Sen case<br><br>(ii) Illustration of Bhanwar Singh v Puran Case<br><br>(iii) Illustration of M. Yogendra v Leelamma case<br><br>(5) Nature of the property inherited by son from his divided father<br><br>(6) Nature of the interest in Mitakshara coparcenary property devolved under proviso to old s. 6<br><br>8. Heirs can’t demand partition of the self acquired property of a Hindu during his life time<br><br>(8-i) Illustration of Sadhineni Rajani v Sadhineni Hymavathi case<br><br>9. Succession on death of female limited owner<br><br>10. Overriding effect over the Hindu Widows' Re-Marriage Act, 1856<br><br>11. Legal status of the Nominee<br><br>(1) Nomination in case of Life insurance agent<br><br>(2) Nomination in case of Life insurance policy<br><br>(3) Nominee in case of national savings certificates<br><br>(4) Effect of the Insurance Laws (Amendment) Act, 2015<br><br>(5) Nominee’s status under life insurance policy post Amendment Act, 2015<br><br>(6) Nomination in case of deposit of amount<br><br>(7) Nominee in case of Bank Account<br><br>(8) Nomination in case of security holder<br><br>(9) Nomination in case of a provident fund<br><br>(10) Succession certificate<br><br>(11) Word ‘Legal Representative’<br><br>12. Class I heirs' right to be a necessary party in a suit<br><br>13. Failure in payment of consideration in lieu of relinquishment of right<br><br>9 Order of succession among heirs in the Schedule<br><br>1. Rule of preference for succession among heirs in Class I and Class II<br><br>(1-i) Illustration of Leelabai v Rajaram<br><br>2. Property of an intestate devolve simultaneously among heirs in Class I<br><br>3. All heirs in Class II cannot succeed together<br><br>4. Word "entry" — connotation of<br><br>(4-i) Illustration of Kumara Pillai v Kunjulekshmi Amma case<br><br>10 Distribution of property among heirs in class I of the Schedule<br><br>1. Manner of distribution of property among heirs in Class I<br><br>2. Rules for distribution of property among heirs in Class I<br><br>(1) Rule 1 of Section 10<br><br>(1-i) Illustration of Paru Bala v Bijubala case<br><br>(2) Rule 2 of Section 10<br><br>(2-i) Illustration of Bulu Das v Moni Das<br><br>(2-ii) Illustration of Muktabai Bhaktadas v Keshav Kisan<br><br>(2-iii) Illustration of Ramanlata v Saurabh case<br><br>(3) Rule 3 of Section 10<br><br>(3-i) Phrase ‘heirs in the branch of the predeceased son or predeceased daughter’<br><br>(3-ii) Illustration<br><br>(4) Rule 4 of Section 10<br><br>(4-i) Per capita and per stirpes distribution<br><br>(4-ii) Illustration<br><br>3. Class I Heirs<br><br>4. Son as Class I Heirs<br><br>(1) Adopted son<br><br>(2) Son born before father's adoption<br><br>(2-i) Illustration of Kalindi Damodar case<br><br>(3) Step-son<br><br>(4) Illegitimate son not falling u/s 16 of Hindu Marriage Act<br><br>(5) Impact of Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 on inheritance rights of illegitimate children<br><br>(6) Son legitimate by virtue of the provisions of Hindu Marriage Act<br><br>(7) Controversy related to rights of illegitimate sons in joint family/ coparcenary property<br><br>(7-i) Illustration of Balkrishna Pandurang v Yeshodabai Balkrishna case<br><br>(8) Illegitimate children not entitled to succeed property of their grandparents<br><br>(9) Solemnization of marriage essential<br><br>(9-i) Illustration of Rameshwar Prasad v Tara Bai case<br><br>(10) Presumption of marriage<br><br>(11) Posthumous son<br><br>5. Daughter as Class I Heirs<br><br>(1) Illustration of Ramabai Padamakar Patil v Rukminibai Vishnu Vekhande case<br><br>(2) Adopted daughter<br><br>(3) Step-daughter<br><br>(4) Daughter born before her father’s adoption<br><br>(4-i) Illustration of Neelawwa v Shivawwa case<br><br>(5) Illegitimate daughter not falling u/s 16 of Hindu Marriage Act<br><br>(5-i) Illustration of Savitri Jaiswal v Saroj case<br><br>(6) Daughter legitimate by virtue of the provisions of Hindu Marriage Act<br><br>(7) Posthumous daughter<br><br>6. Widow as Class I Heirs<br><br>(1) Expression "widow"<br><br>(2) Illustration of Laxmibai v Anasuya case<br><br>(3) Widow inherits simultaneously with other heirs in Class I<br><br>(4) All the widows together takes one share<br><br>(5) Remarriage, unchastity etc. of Widow are no longer disqualifications to inheritance<br><br>(6) Rights of female as widow-wife does not cease without decree of divorce<br><br>(7) Widows right to be impleaded as a party in a partition suit<br><br>7. Mother as Class I Heirs<br><br>8. Other Heirs in Class I<br><br>(1) Children of a pre-deceased son<br><br>(1-i) Illustration of M. Suseelamma v Chief Controlling Revenue Authority case<br><br>(2) Children of a predeceased daughter<br><br>(3) Widow of a pre-deceased son<br><br>(4) Illustration of Lehja Bai v Sewanti Bai case<br><br>(5) Son of a pre-deceased son of a pre-deceased son<br><br>(6) Illustration of Ameenambal Beevi v Gopalasamy case<br><br>9. Construction of expression 'heirs' used in a ‘Will’<br><br>(9-i) Illustration of N. Krishnammal v R. Ekambaram case<br><br>10. Succession of the family pension<br><br>(10-i) Illustration of Nitu v Sheela Rani case<br><br>11 Distribution of property among heirs in class II of the Schedule<br><br>1. Distribution of property among heirs in Class II<br><br>2. Heirs mentioned in any one entry in Class II take an equal share<br><br>3. No order of preference inter se the heirs in same entry of Class II<br><br>3(1) Illustration of Satya Charan v Urmilla case<br><br>3(2) Illustration of Thanthoni Naicker v Kuppammal case<br><br>3(3) Illustration of Deep Narayan Singh v Sarjan Singh case<br><br>4. Heirs specified in Class II of the Schedule<br><br>5. Heir in Entry I of Class II: Father<br><br>6. Heir in Entry II of Class II<br><br>(1) Son’s daughter’s son<br><br>(2) Son’s daughter’s daughter<br><br>(3) Brother<br><br>(3-i) Illustration of Patiram v Mula case<br><br>(4) Sister<br><br>(5) Full blood brother or sister preferred to half blood brother or sister in Entry II<br><br>7. Heir in Entry III of Class II<br><br>(1) Daughter’s son’s son<br><br>(2) Daughter’s son’s daughter, daughter’s daughter’s son and daughter’s daughter’s daughter.<br><br>8. Heirs in Entry IV of Class II<br><br>(1) Brother’s son<br><br>(2) Sister’s son<br><br>(3) Brother’s daughter<br><br>(4) Sister’s daughter<br><br>(5) Illustration of Sunderlal v Tejila case<br><br>9. Heir in Entry V of Class II<br><br>(1) Father’s father<br><br>(2) Father’s mother<br><br>10. Heir in Entry VI of Class II<br><br>(1) Father’s widow<br><br>(2) Brother’s widow<br><br>11. Heir in Entry VII of Class II<br><br>(1) Father’s brother<br><br>(2) Father’s sister<br><br>12. Heir in Entry VIII of Class II<br><br>(1) Mother’s father<br><br>(2) Mother’s mother<br><br>13. Heir in Entry IX of Class II<br><br>(1) Mother’s brother<br><br>(2) Mother’s sister<br><br>14. Issue of discrimination on the ground of gender<br><br>12 Order of succession among agnates and cognates<br><br>1. Succession among agnates and cognates<br><br>2. Agnates — Connotation<br><br>3. Cognates — Connotation<br><br>4. Illustration<br><br>(1) Thirunavukkarasu v Rajavel case<br><br>(2) Krushna Chandra v Nisamani Bewa case<br><br>5. Expression ‘related by blood or adoption’<br><br>6. Wife’ Brother is not a cognate<br><br>7. No limit of number of degrees in recognizing an agnate or cognate<br><br>8. No preference in the order of succession on the ground of gender or sex<br><br>9. Categories of agnates<br><br>(1) Agnate related solely by degree of descent<br><br>(2) Agnate related solely by degree of ascent<br><br>(3) Agnate related by both the degrees<br><br>10. Categories of cognates<br><br>(1) Cognate related solely by degree of descent<br><br>(2) Cognate related solely by degree of ascent<br><br>(3) Cognate related by both the degrees<br><br>11. General meaning of degrees of ascent, degrees of descent etc.<br><br>12. Rules to determine order of succession among agnates and cognates<br><br>(1) Rule 1 — Heir having fewer or no degrees of ascent is preferred<br><br>(2) Rule 2 — Heir having fewer or no degrees of descent is preferred<br><br>(2-i) Illustration of Milkhi Ram v Milkhi Ram case<br><br>(2-ii) Illustration of V.C. Desa Bathudu v P. Dilli Achari case<br><br>(3) Rule 3 — Heirs take simultaneously<br><br>(3-i) Illustration of Umrao Devi v Hulas Mal case<br><br>(3-ii) Illustration of Naresh v Deepak Singh case<br><br>(3-iii) Illustration of Gurcharan Kaur v Pritam Singh case<br><br>13. The rule of degree of relationship u/s 12 applies before the rule of full blood preference over half blood u/s 18<br><br>(13-i) Illustration of Ram Singari Devi v Govind Thakur case<br><br>13 Computation of degrees<br><br>1. Computation of degrees<br><br>2. Illustration on computation of degrees<br><br>(1) Paternal grandfather’s mother<br><br>(2) Daughter’s son’s daughter’s son<br><br>(3) Mother’s mother’s brother’s son<br><br>14 Property of a female Hindu to be her absolute property<br><br>1. Nature, scope and object of Section 14<br><br>(1-i) Illustration of Marabasappa v Ningappa case<br><br>(1-ii) Illustration of Chinnammal v Kannagi case<br><br>(1-iii) Illustration of Chinnappa Gounder v Valliammal case<br><br>2. Section 14 is retrospective in some sense<br><br>3. Constitutional validity of Section 14<br><br>4. Intent behind the provision of Section 14(1)<br><br>5. Phrase ‘female Hindu’ u/s 14 — connotation<br><br>(5-i) Illustration of Vidya v Nand Ram case<br><br>6. Expression 'full owner'<br><br>7. Adoption does not effect the property of which a female Hindu is a full owner<br><br>(7-i) Illustration of Yamunabai v Ram Maharaj case<br><br>(7-ii) Illustration of Kesh |

## Details

- **Price:** 1040.0 INR
- **Vendor:** Bharat Law House
- **Tags:** Professional Books

## Variants

| Variant | Price | Available |
|---------|-------|-----------|
| Default Title | 1040.00 INR | In stock |

## Images

- Bharat's Commentary on HINDU SUCCESSION ACT, 1956 by Neelam Kumar Jain - BuyTestSeries.in

---

> Source: [BuyTestSeries.in](https://buytestseries.in/products/bharats-commentary-on-hindu-succession-act-1956-by-neelam-kumar-jain)
> Updated: 2026-10-24
